open_in_newOriginal article
The used Tesla market is crumbling

The used Tesla market is crumbling

  • 17.03.2025 18:46
  • wral.com
  • Keywords: Tesla, Musk

The used Tesla market is declining due to political controversies surrounding Elon Musk, increased competition from other electric vehicles, and rapid depreciation, making it difficult for owners to sell their cars at decent prices.

Tesla ReportsTSLAsentiment_dissatisfied

Estimated market influence

Tesla

Tesla

Negativesentiment_dissatisfied
Analyst rating: Neutral

Decreasing resale values and sales due to political controversies and competition.

CarGurus

Negativesentiment_dissatisfied
Analyst rating: N/A

Used Tesla prices falling more than average used cars.

Context

Analysis of the Used Tesla Market Decline

Key Findings and Data Points

  • Used Tesla Resale Values:

    • Cybertruck resale value is down by 58% compared to its original price.
    • Overall used Tesla prices are falling at more than double the rate of the average used car market.

  • Market Demand:

    • Searches for used Teslas decreased by 16% over the past month.
    • Demand for non-Tesla electric vehicles increased by 28% year-over-year.

  • Political Impact:

    • Tesla loyalty in blue states dropped from 72% to 65% between Q4 2023 and Q4 2024.
    • Repeat buyers in red states slightly increased from 47.6% to 48.2%.

  • Competition:

    • Number of used EV models available in February: 76, up from 58 the previous year.
    • Tesla faces stiff competition in China and slumping sales in Europe.

  • Leasing Impact:

    • Approximately 70% of used EVs are leased, leading to a surge in used Tesla availability.

  • Depreciation Rates:

    • Electric vehicles depreciate 11% faster than gasoline-powered cars due to concerns about battery health and software updates.

Market Trends and Business Insights

  • Declining Resale Values: The combination of increased competition, political controversies, and market saturation has led to a sharp decline in used Tesla values.
  • Political Backlash: Negative sentiment toward Elon Musk, particularly among left-leaning consumers, has weakened Tesla's brand loyalty in blue states.
  • Strategic Pricing: Tesla’s price cuts in the new car market are putting pressure on used car dealerships, forcing them to lower prices for used Teslas.

Competitive Dynamics

  • Rising Competition: The EV market is becoming more crowded, with 76 models available compared to 58 a year ago. This intensifies competition and reduces Tesla’s market dominance.
  • Brand Perception: Negative publicity surrounding Musk and Tesla has created buyer hesitancy, particularly among politically aligned consumers.

Strategic Considerations

  • Long-Term Effects: The decline in used Tesla values could impact consumer trust and loyalty, potentially affecting new car sales in the long term.
  • Regulatory Impacts: While not directly addressed, regulatory changes or shifts in government support for EVs could further influence market dynamics.

Conclusion

The used Tesla market is facing significant challenges due to a combination of factors, including political controversies, increased competition, and market saturation. While Tesla continues to gain traction among politically conservative consumers, the long-term impact of declining resale values and negative sentiment remains uncertain.