open_in_newOriginal article
‘He claims to be a nihilist’: I told my friend to sell his Tesla shares. He did not appreciate my advice. Was I wrong?

‘He claims to be a nihilist’: I told my friend to sell his Tesla shares. He did not appreciate my advice. Was I wrong?

  • 22.03.2025 13:21
  • msn.com
  • Keywords: Tesla, Musk, Elon Musk

A friend advised another to sell Tesla shares due to concerns about the stock's volatility and political ties, leading to strained relations. The situation highlights how financial advice can clash with personal or political beliefs, risking friendships.

Meta ProductsTesla ServicesNvidia ServicesTesla ProductsNvidia ProductsTSLAsentiment_dissatisfied

Estimated market influence

Tesla

Tesla

Negativesentiment_dissatisfied
Analyst rating: Neutral

The article discusses Tesla's stock decline and sales issues, which negatively impacts the company.

Musk

Negativesentiment_dissatisfied
Analyst rating: N/A

Elon Musk's political activities are harming Tesla's reputation and sales.

Context

Analysis of Tesla Stock Advice Fallout and Market Implications

Key Facts and Data Points

  • Friend's Investment: The friend owned two Teslas and had his entire retirement portfolio invested in Tesla stock. He identified as a Democrat and a nihilist.

  • Stock Performance:

    • Tesla stock dropped approximately 50% from its peak of $477 at the end of last year.
    • Despite this, it remains higher than its price a year ago ($170).
    • Long-term investors are still in the green compared to five years ago when the stock was around $23.

  • Sales Decline:

    • In California (Tesla's largest U.S. market), registrations fell by 7.8% in Q4 2024, with a total decline of 11.6% for 2024.
    • Tesla sales in Europe dropped over 50% year-over-year in January 2025.

  • Political Impact:

    • 85% of Morgan Stanley clients believe Elon Musk's political activities harm Tesla.
    • Analysts suggest Musk's political involvement and distractions (e.g., Twitter/X, SpaceX) may hinder Tesla's growth.

  • Analyst Predictions:

    • J.P. Morgan analyst Ryan Brinkman slashed Q1 delivery forecast by 20% to 355,000 units.
    • Price target reduced from $135 to $120.
    • Questioned Tesla's place among the "Magnificent Seven" tech stocks due to high valuation (85x earnings vs. others as "profit machines").

Market Trends and Business Impact

  • Investment Diversification: The advice to diversify investments highlights the risk of overexposure to a single stock, especially one with significant political risks.
  • Brand Image and Sales: Tesla's declining sales in key markets (U.S., Europe) and negative perception due to Musk's political activities signal potential long-term issues.
  • Investor Sentiment: Political polarization and investor sentiment shifts could lead to further stock volatility.

Competitive Dynamics

  • Market Share Loss: Competitors like traditional automakers offering hybrids and EVs, along with potential MAGA supporter sales, may not offset Tesla's losses.
  • Analyst Concerns: Analysts warn of continued stock decline and question Tesla's leadership in the tech sector.

Strategic Considerations

  • Diversification Advice: While prudent, such advice can strain relationships if perceived as judgmental or political.
  • Investment Tact: Balancing financial advice with sensitivity to personal beliefs and politics is crucial for maintaining relationships.

Long-Term Effects and Regulatory Impacts

  • Political Risks: Musk's involvement in politics may lead to regulatory challenges and further impact Tesla's global sales.
  • Investor Caution: Investors should consider diversification and be cautious of companies with significant political exposure.

Conclusion

The situation underscores the importance of balancing financial advice with sensitivity, especially when involving politically charged investments. The market implications highlight the risks of overinvesting in a company facing significant political and competitive challenges.