EU Comes Out Swinging Against Apple, Google

EU Comes Out Swinging Against Apple, Google

  • 19.03.2025 15:50
  • thurrott.com
  • Keywords: EU, Apple, Google

The European Commission has fined Apple and Google for violating the Digital Markets Act. Apple must allow third-party devices to integrate with iOS, while Google’s Search and Play services are accused of favoring Alphabet’s own offerings over competitors. Both companies have expressed dissatisfaction with the rulings.

Apple ProductsAlphabet ProductsApple ServicesAAPLsentiment_dissatisfied
open_in_newOriginal article

Estimated market influence

Apple

Apple

Negativesentiment_dissatisfied
Analyst rating: Buy

The EC has determined that Apple is violating the DMA by not allowing third-party devices to fully interoperate with iOS. Apple must comply with 9 specific features to allow compatibility with devices like smartwatches, headphones, TVs, etc., and improve transparency for developers seeking interoperability.

Google

Negativesentiment_dissatisfied
Analyst rating: N/A

The EC has found that Google Search and Google Play are violating the DMA. Google must ensure fair treatment of third-party services in search results and allow app developers to inform users about alternative cheaper offers without additional costs. The EC also notes that Google's fees may be excessive.

European Commission

Positivesentiment_satisfied
Analyst rating: N/A

The European Commission is enforcing the DMA, requiring both Apple and Google to make changes to comply with regulations aimed at promoting fair competition and interoperability in digital markets.

Context

Analysis and Summary: EU vs. Apple and Google under DMA

Key Findings:

  • DMA Violations: Both Apple and Google have been found in violation of the Digital Markets Act (DMA).
    • Apple: Must comply with interoperability obligations in iOS, allowing third-party devices like smartwatches, headphones, and TVs to integrate seamlessly with Apple’s ecosystem.
    • Google: Search and Google Play violate DMA by favoring Alphabet’s own services over competitors and restricting alternative purchase options.

Compliance Requirements:

  • Apple:

    • Must adapt 9 features in iOS to ensure third-party devices can interoperate similarly with Apple’s products.
    • Improve transparency and effectiveness of developer processes for interoperability.
    • Deadline: March 2024.

  • Google:

    • Remove preferential treatment of Alphabet’s services in Google Search results.
    • Allow app developers to inform users about alternative cheaper offers and make purchases without additional costs.
    • Address concerns over excessive app store fees, which could set a precedent for broader industry scrutiny.

Market Impact:

  • Consumer Choice: Enhanced interoperability will likely increase consumer options and competition in Europe.
  • App Developers: Easier access to Google Play’s user base and fairer treatment of third-party services could stimulate innovation and growth.
  • Innovation: Companies may face slower innovation due to regulatory constraints, as seen in Apple’s statement about being “wrapped in red tape.”

Competitive Dynamics:

  • Apple: Criticizes the EC for hindering innovation and公平性 (fairness) in competition. Likely to challenge the decision formally.
  • Google: Argues that compliance would reduce user experience and expose Europeans to more malware, framing it as a trade-off between openness and security.

Strategic Considerations:

  • Both companies may appeal or seek to influence regulators while adapting their business models to comply with DMA requirements.
  • Potential long-term effects include:
    • Market Structure: More fragmented ecosystems as third-party devices gain prominence.
    • Regulatory Precedent: Sets a framework for other regions to regulate tech giants, potentially altering global market dynamics.

Long-Term Effects:

  • Could lead to increased competition and reduced monopolistic practices in digital markets.
  • May encourage alternative revenue models for app developers and hardware manufacturers.

Regulatory Impacts:

  • The EC’s actions signal stricter enforcement of antitrust rules in the tech sector, particularly regarding interoperability and fair competition.
  • Companies may face similar scrutiny globally, influencing how they operate across borders.

This analysis highlights the significant regulatory shifts reshaping digital markets, with profound implications for competition, innovation, and consumer choice.